Skip to content
Shark Tank Index

Customer Acquisition Cost Needs New Customers

Published

A founder says the business gets customers for $10. Before deciding what that means, ask what was counted. Advertising spend divided by orders is not automatically the cost of acquiring a new customer. Repeat orders can make the number look much smaller.

BDC's customer-acquisition explanation relates the costs of winning new customers to the number acquired. It also distinguishes work spent acquiring customers from work spent keeping existing ones. A useful comparison needs the same definition on both sides.

Count people or businesses once

Suppose a campaign costs $12,000 and produces 1,200 orders. Of those orders, 800 come from existing customers, while 400 represent first purchases by 400 new customers. Spend divided by orders is $10. Spend divided by newly acquired customers is $30.

Neither calculation changes the $12,000 spent. They answer different questions. The $30 result is campaign spend per new customer, not yet a verified acquisition cost. Some of that spending may have served existing customers, so the acquisition-related share still needs to be established.

The example assumes every first-purchase order comes from a different new customer and that the campaign accounts for all 400 acquisitions. Real attribution may be more complicated. An order count without distinct customer information cannot resolve it.

Check the costs included

First separate acquisition spending from work aimed at existing customers. Then identify any other acquisition costs, such as relevant creative work, sales activity or campaign support. A media-only number and a wider acquisition figure do not include the same work.

If all $12,000 were established as acquisition-related, adding $4,000 of other acquisition costs would bring the total to $16,000. Dividing by the same 400 new customers would give $40. That is conditional on the allocation; the mixed-order campaign alone has not established it.

Compare contribution, not just order value

A $50 first order does not leave $50 to cover a $40 acquisition cost. Product, fulfilment and other relevant costs consume part of that revenue. If the first order leaves $15 before acquisition cost, the business needs more contribution later to recover the assumed $40.

Repeat purchasing may provide that contribution, but it needs evidence of how often customers return and what those later orders contribute. An expectation that buyers will return is different from an observed history of repeat orders.

When following the next pitch, record the cost scope, period, new-customer count and any repeat-purchase assumption beside the acquisition claim. Those details let you compare the founder's explanation fairly without treating a small headline percentage or dollar amount as a complete business model.